Architecture of Harm, Episode 4 · Chapter 5.

The Substance Use Crisis

THE OTHER HALF OF LAST WEEK’S NUMBER

The chart said: urine drug screen positive for marijuana.

A clinical exam room under harsh fluorescent overhead light
A positive screen starts in a room like this one — routine, until it isn’t.
Photo: clinical exam room · editorial stock, Labora Collective library
THE LEADING MEDICAL KILLER

Comorbidity goes mostly untreated.

~70%
of pregnant people with substance use disorder also carry a mental health condition
<25%
get treated for both conditions
THE LEADING MEDICAL KILLER

Overdose is now the leading medical cause of maternal death.

81%
rise among pregnant and postpartum women, 2017–2020
3×
the mortality rate among women 35–44, 2018–2021
THE LEADING MEDICAL KILLER

Same women, same year — two different causes of death.

51.4%
of mental-health-attributed pregnancy-related deaths in 2022 were overdose
45.4%
were suicide
Same review committees · Architecture of Harm, Ch. 05
Cross-section of the human uteroplacental unit at term. The villous tree projects into the intervillous space; fentanyl crosses the villous membrane directly into a fetal capillary. A maternal spiral artery is narrowed at one point by xylazine, with reduced flow downstream; naloxone does not reverse this narrowing.

Fentanyl crosses the placenta directly; xylazine narrows the flow that feeds it

WHAT IT DOES IN PREGNANCY

October 2023: a fentanyl birth defect syndrome.

Distinctive facial features
Microcephaly
Cleft palate
“Rocker-bottom” feet
HOW IT GOT HERE

Naloxone does not reverse xylazine.

99 2018 6,020 2023 FENTANYL-XYLAZINE OVERDOSE DEATHS · TWO OBSERVED YEARS ON FILE, NOT AN ANNUAL SERIES
Fentanyl–xylazine overdose deaths: 99 (2018) → 6,020 (2023)
HOW IT GOT HERE

2021 was the first year overdose deaths passed 100,000.

All US drug overdose deaths · every age, both sexes COVID-19pandemic years 025k50k75k100k 20152016201720182019202020212022202320242025 109,413the peak70,6372025 · provisional
CDC VSRR 2015–2025 · all US overdose deaths, all ages — not maternal-specific. 2025 provisional.
TREATMENT OPTIONS FOR PREGNANT PATIENTS

Medication is the standard of care — not withdrawal.

A clinician reviewing vitals with a pregnant patient
1
Buprenorphine or methadone — the standard of care.
2
Withdrawal alone: 59–90%+ relapse.
3
NAS is expected and treatable.
4
Breastfeeding encouraged on either.
5
Keep naloxone on hand.
Photo · Labora Collective library
THE ACCESS GAP IS A GEOGRAPHY

Most U.S. counties have no buprenorphine prescriber at all.

60.7%
of U.S. counties had no buprenorphine prescriber at all, 2024
Two responses

Same diagnosis — different door

TREATMENT
Medication + care team
Medication, prenatal care, support — better outcomes for her and the baby.
VS
PUNISHMENT
Report + charge
A criminal file, a child-welfare case — decided by which system reached her first.
ACOG, 2011 — incarceration doesn’t reduce drug use

Incarcerated women, 1980–2023

Incarcerated women in the US rose from 26,326 in 1980 to 186,244 in 2023; more than 80% have histories of abuse.
Sentencing Project; Survived & Punished
BEYOND FENTANYL

No medication covers most of what’s driving overdose now.

Stimulants — meth and cocaine, 4.1 million affected — have no FDA-approved medication at all.
Methamphetamine is now present in about 35% of opioid overdose deaths.
Alcohol — 28.9 million affected — fewer than 9% ever get medication.
THE PIPELINE

How substance use becomes the next generation’s risk.

A
Substance use disorder
B
Neonatal abstinence syndrome
C
CPS referral
D
Family separation
E
ACE accumulation
The same risk, next generation.
THE PIPELINE

The risk carries into her child’s own future pregnancy.

3.06
preeclampsia odds ratio in the child’s own future pregnancy (4+ ACEs)
WHAT IS BEING DONE TO THE SYSTEM NOW

The system that treats this is being defunded. The system that punishes it is expanding.

WHAT IS BEING DONE TO THE SYSTEM NOW

Syringe programs cut disease transmission — and lost their funding.

A public needle drop box for safe syringe disposal
Cut HIV/HCV transmission ~50%. Defunded in 2025; 37 states lost eligibility.
Photo · Adobe Stock (licensed)
What is being done to the system now

The money arrived. The coverage that pays for treatment is being cut.

$50B+
in opioid settlement money, arriving once
Jan 2027
Medicaid work requirements begin — millions projected to lose coverage by 2034
One check, once — against the coverage that pays every year.
Opioid settlement distributions · KFF
The logic

Punishment is not treatment.

You cannot arrest your way out of depression, incarcerate your way out of addiction, or shackle a safe delivery into being. Substitute a cage for care, and a treatable condition becomes a lethal one. Same architecture — the body pays.
What would move it

Treat, don’t prosecute

Decriminalize — fund treatment, not charges.
Close the buprenorphine gap — 60.7% of counties have no prescriber.
Fund stimulant-use-disorder medication — cover contingency management, as CA Medicaid does.
Restore the privacy rule — end mandatory reporting in pregnancy.
Evidence-based and reversible · ACOG-aligned
The receipt, not the argument

A treatable condition, met with punishment.

FOR PROVIDERS

Medication is the standard of care — not withdrawal.

A smiling Black woman physician in a white coat and stethoscope reviews a tablet with a patient at her clinic desk
Buprenorphine or methadone is the standard — not withdrawal.
Your chart is discoverable — know what a positive screen becomes.
Medication is the standard; the record can be subpoenaed.
OB-GYN · Addiction Medicine
FOR HEALTH SYSTEMS

The access gap is a policy choice.

A woman alone in a boardroom
Fewer than 5% of jails and prisons offer all three OUD medications.
60.7% of counties have no buprenorphine prescriber.
No prescriber, no jail medication — the same patient fails twice.
Health system · Policy
FOR PATIENTS AND THEIR SUPPORT SYSTEM

Addiction is a medical condition, not a moral failing.

Medication in pregnancy is the standard of care.
Breastfeeding is encouraged on methadone or buprenorphine.
Naloxone saves a mother’s life in an overdose — use it, then get emergency care.
FOR ADVOCATES

Three policy asks, evidence-based and reversible.

Reporting
End mandatory reporting of substance use in pregnancy to law enforcement.
Privacy
Restore the reproductive-health privacy rule.
Medication
Push for a stimulant-use-disorder medication and Medicaid-covered contingency management in every state.
TAKE THIS HOME

Tobacco, Alcohol & Drugs in Pregnancy

Covers both: overdose, and stopping too fast.
← The record Arrow keys, or tap the sides